By: Jamie Rochester, Queensland Law Society
Artificial intelligence (AI) tools such as ChatGPT, Copilot and Gemini are changing the way people access information. AI features are also becoming common in other software like Google Search or Microsoft Office.
Whether you're dealing with a workplace issue, family law matter, neighbourhood dispute, contract problem or court proceeding, it has never been easier to get an instant answer to a legal question.
For many Queenslanders, the temptation is obvious. If AI can explain the law in seconds, do you still need a lawyer? The answer depends on what you're asking AI to do.
What AI can help with
AI can be a useful starting point when you're trying to understand a legal issue.
For example, it may help you:
- understand legal terms and concepts
- learn how a legal process works
- prepare questions to ask a lawyer
- organise information and documents
- find publicly available resources
For many people, AI can provide a quicker and more accessible way to begin researching a legal issue.
Where problems start
The risk comes when people begin treating AI as a substitute for legal advice or placing too much reliance on a tool that is not well suited to the question it is being asked. The Fair Work Commission has provided useful resources explaining how AI might be used in work related claims, and how to avoid some of the most common problems. Some of those principles apply in other legal claims as well.
Legal matters are rarely as simple as they appear. Two people might have the same question: "Can my employer dismiss me?" But the answer may be completely different depending on the facts, evidence, employment history, industry, workplace policies and many other factors.
AI cannot properly assess these nuances in the same way a lawyer can. While AI can provide general information, it cannot accurately apply the law to your individual circumstances or advise you on the best course of action.
Can AI get the law wrong?
Yes. Queensland Courts have publicly warned that generative AI systems can provide inaccurate information, refer to cases that do not exist, incorrectly summarise laws, or rely on overseas legal systems that do not apply in Australia.
The challenge is that these answers can sound convincing. Unlike a legal database, generative AI does not independently verify that its response is correct before providing it.
If you're relying on that information to make decisions about your employment, family, finances or future, the stakes can be high.
Should you upload legal documents into AI?
Many people upload contracts, court documents, letters from lawyers, wills, employment records, and family law documents into AI platforms to ask questions or generate summaries.
In some cases it is illegal to do so. In others it may damage your legal rights. Entering confidential, legally privileged, private or suppressed information into “public” AI tools may permit that information to be shared with tech companies to train new AI systems. Once that happens the data may no longer be confidential. If the information was private or obtained by you from another party this can be contempt of court, punishable by stiff fines. If the information was confidential to you the other side may now be allowed to read it because Legal Privilege does not apply to information that is no longer confidential.
Using AI to send dozens of pages of instructions and arguments to your own lawyer often increases costs without any benefit to you.
If you've already engaged a lawyer, it is essential that you discuss AI use with them before uploading documents to an AI platform.
What about representing yourself in court?
AI can prepare court documents, legal arguments and submissions. Unfortunately, the technology is still quite unreliable in 2026.
While AI may help with formatting, structure or identifying issues for further research, Queensland Courts and other courts (such as the Family Court) have made it clear that people remain responsible for the accuracy of any information they provide to a court or tribunal.
You must ensure:
- any laws, court cases or examples it refers to are real
- the information is accurate
- the information is up to date
- the facts and details relate to your situation
Providing incorrect information to a court can have serious consequences, regardless of whether it came from AI. It is especially important that every line and every fact in a witness statement or affidavit is checked. It is a criminal offence to submit false evidence to a Court. Some courts prohibit use of an AI to produce witness statements. Even if not expressly prohibited, binding court rules (“practice directions”) all require extreme caution when using AI to produce evidence. Check the court website for up to date practice directions before using AI in any capacity.
So when should you speak to a lawyer?
AI can be helpful when you're looking for general information. However, you should strongly consider speaking to a lawyer if you are:
- considering taking legal action
- involved in a dispute
- going to court or a tribunal
- facing criminal allegations
- signing or reviewing an important legal document
- unsure about your rights or obligations
A lawyer's role is not simply to explain the law. They assess your circumstances, identify risks, review evidence and provide advice tailored to your situation. That's something AI cannot currently do.
If you need legal advice tailored to your circumstances, You & The Law's Find a Solicitor tool can help you find a Queensland solicitor based on your location and area of legal need.

.png?lang=en-AU&ext=.png)
